SILENCING, AGENCY, AND THE WRITING OF HISTORY

HORACIO LARA AND MAPUCHE NARRATIVES BETWEEN THE COLONIAL AND THE NATIONAL

Authors

Keywords:

Ambivalência narrativa. Historiografia chilena. Pacificação da Araucanía.

Abstract

This article examines Horacio Lara Marchant's Crónica de la Araucanía (1888-1889)

through a close reading of its two volumes and paratextual materials, combined with a stratified

sample of evidence concerning its reception between 1889 and 2024. The analysis assesses

the extent to which the work may be understood as a counter-narrative to Chilean national

historiography and the limits of the silencing hypothesis. The results indicate that Lara

acknowledged Mapuche sovereignty and diplomatic agency while framing that recognition

within civilizational categories and a teleology of territorial integration. Later reception ranged

from patriotic celebration and documentary appropriation to criticism of the national narrative.

The article argues that the work constitutes a partial counter-narrative whose circulation was

uneven and whose meanings were historically contested.

Author Biography

Saulo José Mello da Silva, Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora

Pós-graduando em História na modalidade Mestrado pela Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)

Published

2026-08-27

How to Cite

Mello da Silva, S. J. (2026). SILENCING, AGENCY, AND THE WRITING OF HISTORY: HORACIO LARA AND MAPUCHE NARRATIVES BETWEEN THE COLONIAL AND THE NATIONAL. Horizontes Históricos, 12(1), 132–150. Retrieved from https://periodicos.ufs.br/HORIZONTES/article/view/25005